VDARE LETTERS - Archived

Joe Guzzardi, Letters Editor - Email For Publication

In general, VDARE.COM prefers shorter letters, not to exceed 300 words, to longer ones. Letters of all lengths, however, may be edited for grammar, style and content with the assurance that the reader's point will remain clear. Abusive letters have a high probability of being posted with email address. Every effort is made to answer in-coming mail although we do not always meet that goal.  Please re-send any mail which did not receive a response if you care to.

Letters for Recent, 2008, 2007, 2006, 2005, 2004, 2003

 

A Southern Sympathizer Suggests Strom=Sharon?

A Heads-up from NumbersUsa

The Father Of An Autistic Child Suspects Mass Immigration

A Reader Watches the Wall Street Journal

A Latin American Student Reports Passing His Midterm; We Comment.

A Reader Proposes Educating WSJ About The Citizen Child Flaw

A Czech Reader Reports Media-Induced False Consciousness Among His Students

A Seattle Reader Reports Canadian Immigration Sex Scandal In Beijing

John Vinson Reports An Exposé Of Government Immigration-Enthusiast Funding

A Reader Ponders Trent Lott On Immigration Reform

A Reader Reports U.K. Economists Querying Immigration Too

An Australian Reader Critiques The Economist; Peter Brimelow Comments

A Reader Warns Of A Lame Duck Stealth Amnesty

The (Zip) Code Of The Tarantoad

English For The Children’s Ron Unz Comments On Joe Guzzardi

“Robert Taft” Notes That Bilingual Means Double-Tongued

A Reader Reports PC Grinch Getting Early Start In San Diego

Glynn Custred Sighs About Social Science

An American Programmer Contemplates His Layoff

Howard Foster Reports A Victory Against Illegals’ Employers

A Reasonable Chinese Immigrant Reflects On 9/11; Peter Brimelow Responds

A Representative Reader Reacts to Ehrenreich; Peter Brimelow Responds.

A Reader Asks – “Urban Woes” Or Immigration Woes?

An Australian Reader Eyes the New York Times Again

A Reader Challenges Steve Sailer On Miscegenation 

Ground Zero In Occupied America

An American Reader Eyes British Immigration Stirrings

An Australian Reader Has His Eye On The New York Times

An Ex-Hippie Reader Blesses Us with Peace and Love…Sort Of

A friendly lawyer writes from the District of Columbia

A Reader Says We Shouldn’t Be Called “Anti-Immigration.”

A Democratic Reader Wonders If He’s Alone

A Reader Points Out The Gregorian Calendar Is Politically Incorrect

A Reader Notes That Hayek Worried About Immigrants

Equal Opportunity Satire On J. Goldberg From The Texas Mercury

A Reader Rebukes Jacoby

A Reader Says 245(I) Really Is As Bad As Painted

A Protestant Professor Ponders Pope Jonah

A Reader Ponders Pat and Population

Humberto Fontova on Mexicans vs. Cubans

George Borjas Notes An Immigration Irony

Abolishing Nebraska - A Reader Reports

A Reader Reports Immigration Devouring Its Liberal Parents!

A Reader Reveals Rand Was A Restrictionist!

An Angry Reader Says We Are – Well, He’s Angry.

A Reasonable Reader Worries About Nordicism

An Alabama Reader Reports New GOP Resolution

A Reader Ponders Immigration, Environmentalism And The Everglades

A Reader Ponders Portugal

A Computer Consultant Father Worries About His Son

A School Nurse Sends a Post-Christmas Report From Occupied America

RON UNZ PROTESTS THAT HE IS AN EQUAL OPPORTUNITY SLURRER

A Reader Says Asset Forfeiture Would End Illegal Immigration; Peter Brimelow Comments

A Reader Finally Gets to VDARE.com About Print-Friendly Articles

A Reader Notes A Difference Between U.S. And U.K. Reporting

A Catholic Reader Pronounces VDARE.COM Doctrinally Sound

A Reader And VDARE.COM Meditate on NRO’s Misplaying the Race Card

An Odinist Reader (Aargh!) Surfaces To Reprove Tom Fleming

War Against Christmas I: A Small Victory in MD.

The Thirty-Year War For Immigration Reform -Thomas Fleming Replies To Peter Brimelow

A Reader Reports Santa Has Been Banned - In MD!

Another Reader Banned by FreeRepublic. Which word don't they understand - Free? Or Republic?

A Reader Says Wong Wrong

A READER TRIES GUILT BY ASSOCIATION

A Student asks for VDARE.COM Readers' Help

A Reader Says As Schundler Goes, So Goes GOP “Outreach”

A Reader Says Mona Charen Proposed Deportations Too

Howard Sutherland Comments on Paul Gottfried, Ida Magli and the EUicide of the West

A Non-WASP Reader Reflects On The Great Guzzardi

A Reader Notes "American" Muslims Are Turning Against Bombing

An LA Fireman Endures “Diversity Training.”

Post 9/11, A Catholic Reader Wonders About His Bishops

Glynn Custred asks “Where’s Vicente?” VDARE.com Answers

An Anonymous Reader Smears VDARE.com In A Letter To D. Horowitz, Kindly Copying Us And Many Others; Peter Brimelow Comments

A Californian Wonders - First Arabs, Next Chinese?

A Reader Remembers FAIR, Sen. Abraham and Osama Bin Laden

A Reader Is Unimpressed by Paul Gigot’s Farewell Column

Brenda Walker Wonders About Bush’s “Faith-Based” Ploy

A Reader Says Fox-Bush is not an "Amnesty" as Defined

An American Reader Deplores Paul Gigot’s Immigrant Bashing

A Reader Investigates USA TODAY’s Cheap-Labor Boosterism

A READER COMMENTS ON THE INS COLLAPSE

Abolishing America - A Reader Reports from the School Front

A Reader Remembers Operation Wetback; Even If National Review Doesn't

"Indian Immigrant" Comments On "Asian" Rioting

Goldberg Recants On Nativism—Or Does He?

MORE MEXICANS? A READER DESPAIRS. PETER BRIMELOW CONSOLES  HIM.

A Reader Asks About W and the Emerging Democratic Majority; Peter Brimelow Replies.

Goldberg Yields to Gottfried!

Two AZ Readers Are Shocked, Shocked At Any Mention Of R---

An Old American Comments on Sailer vs. Barone

A New Graduate Wonders About Her Commencement Day

An Indian reader asks, “Aren’t Immigrants Just Taking The Jobs Americans Are Too Stupid To Do?”; Norm Matloff Replies

Diversity Strikes in the City of Brotherly Love

Howard Sutherland Eavesdrops On Vicente Fox’s Weekly Radio Address

A Jewish Reader Worries about that Gilmore Proclamation; VDARE Comments.

A Reader Points Out There Is Now Research Showing Immigration Causes American Dropouts

Readers Reflect, Remember NM U.S.A.

An American Monarchist (!) Deplores PC Among U.K. Tories

A Reader Comments on Environmentalism vs. Conservation

A Reader Discovers Vicente Fox's Personal Border Policy

A Reader Asks What Is To Be Done; Peter Brimelow Replies

A Chinese Reader Says Whites Are In "A Death Phase"

A Reader Questions Paul Harvey’s Enthusiasm For Educating Immigrants...

A Reader Notes More Balkanization...

A Reader Writes From Occupied America...

A Catholic Reader Wonders About Those Hispanic "Family Values"

A Reader Writes - This is NOT the Time for Defeatism!!!

Nevada Politician Fawns on Mexican Government...

A Black Talk Show Host Reacts To The Census...

A Reader Finds Evidence Supporting Sailer...

A Reader Disapproves of "Presidents' Day"...

A Reader Comments on Indian Comments...

A Reader Comments on the National Question and the Left Half of the Bell Curve...

A Reader Comments on H1B and Tax Evasion...

A Reader Asks About a Non-Citizen Politician...

A VDARE Reader Responds...

an ANGRY reader...

An Indian Immigrant Comments on Libertarianism and Immigration...

A Historic Admission by Village Voice: Immigrants take Jobs...

A Reader Comments on Things Even Larry Elder Can't Say...

A Reader Comments on Multi-Cultist Holidays...

An Immigrant Reader Asks a Question. VDARE Answers...

Bravo to Mr. Gottfried!

Phyllis Schlafly Speaks!

A Reader Asks About the Nation-state...

A Reader Comments on the Barton Case...

Intelligent Life in Con Establishment?

A Reader Comments on Importing TAs...

A Reader Comments on Caldwell's NY Press Article...

A Reader Comments on Emergency Room Health...

A Reader comments on Foreign TAs...

A Reader comments on Jane Elliot's "Diversity Training."...

A Reader Sees Three Signs of Intelligence...

War Against Christmas 2000: The Winner!

Merry Christmas From VDARE!

None Dare Call It Christmas?

VDARE - Two Jewish Fans Reprove Scott McConnell

Happy New Years From VDARE!

VDARE - Text of Letter from George W. Bush to Cardinal O'Connor, February 25, 2000

VDARE - Letter in Response to America's Imported Caste System, by Steve Sailer

VDARE - Tim Fay's Letter responding to "Census Follies" by Steve Sailer

VDARE Replies to a Sarcastic Reader Who Wrote about Steve Sailer on Immigration & Interracial Marriage

VDARE - Letter from Brenda Walker on Peter Brimelow's Election Commentary

VDARE - Reader Comments on Steve Sailer's "Green Gag"

VDARE - Letters re Peter Brimelow column about Will Kymlicka

VDARE - Khan Letter and Sailer Reply - "America's Imported Caste System"

VDARE - LA Times Calls Dubya's Spanish Lessons A Bad Investment

VDARE - Letter from a [Part] Hispanic Reader

VDARE - A Catholic Reader Comments on "W"

VDARE - A Catholic Reader on HUD

VDARE - Letter from Michael Keegan re Population

VDARE - Letter from Brenda Walker on H1B & Tax Evasion

VDARE - Letter from "Demoralized Republican" to Sen. Trent Lott

VDARE - Letter - A reader writes on immigration and the electoral college

VDARE - Letter on Raoul Lowery Contreras on VDARE

VDARE - More readers respond to The Many Deaths of the GOP

 


 

Letter on  H1B “temporary workers”

I am a scientist with extensive work experience with folks expert in advanced Internet and Unix programming. I might also remark that almost all developments in programming, from the start at machine languages and Fortran, through the latest developments, advanced browsers and Java, are due to native-born citizens. We are the third-largest country in the world already and can certainly come up with the talent if the rewards are proportional to the effort. As they would be if salaries were not undercut by imported labor.

H1B visas are interference with the market. If no H1Bs, then salaries would go up and smart citizens who go into other jobs like lawyers and financiers and physics would go into programming.

Importing workers interferes with the natural working of market mechanisms. This should especially conflict with Republican doctrine; it is the government interfering with the market.

Republicans might respond that it is a step toward a completely open world market in everything. But if so, let's import lawyers, etc. Their salaries are too high.

“Scientist”

Peter Brimelow (an imported journalist) writes: I charted surprisingly high unemployment rates among e.g. math Ph.Ds in Forbes May 31 1999.  The native-born tend to back off glutted fields, but their place is taken by foreign students.


The price of Mexican residency

Apparently, most immigrants from Mexico wouldn't qualify for immigration to Mexico. Check out the "proof of income" requirements for FM-3 and FM-2 visas (non-immigrant and prospective-immigrant residence, respectively):

http://www.mexconnect.com/
mex_/visa.html


A hostile reader comments

Distortion

So it turns out your article headed "British police go undercover to eavesdrop on restaurant patrons making 'racist' remarks," is actually about British police going undercover to enforce
laws against HARASSMENT of minority waiters, a detail conveniently omitted from the header.  And they talk about the 'liberal media' distorting
the news...

Stan Kohls
stankohls@dock.net

******

RE: Jane Elliott

From the following site: http://www.hrpress-diversity.com/blueyed.html "In Blue Eyed, we join a diverse group of 40 employees from the Midwest - blacks, Hispanics, whites, women, and men. The blue-eyed members participate in an exercise that involves a pseudo-scientific explanations of their inferiority, culturally biased IQ tests, and blatant disrespect. In just a few hours under Elliott's withering regime, we see grown professionals become despondent and distracted, stumbling over the simplest commands. Black members of the group forcefully remind whites that they undergo similar stresses, not just for a few hours in a controlled experiment, but every day of their lives. And Elliott points out that sexism, homophobia, and ageism are just as damaging."

There is no way the DOE was "unaware" of her views. By the way, the root site http://www.hrpress-diversity.com/ is one scary place.

Jefry Allen

******

RE: Bilingualism

Although I agree completely that abolishing bilingual education is a good thing in and of itself and needs no further justification, I would also add that the argument that retaining immigrant languages would help them or America in international business is bogus. Most immigrant kids who aren't from middle-class families in their countries of origin (i.e., almost all of them) speak only rural dialects or barrio slang. This will help them in a business meeting in Buenos Aires about as much as a command of Rastafarian dialect will help one in a meeting at Lloyds of London. They need to learn the business-standard versions of their languages of origin (assuming they want to) in foreign-language classes at the appropriate age. Teaching them to speak proper Spanish as youths in order to teach them subjects in that language is almost as hard as teaching them English, but a lot less rewarding.

James C. Bennett

******

Bilingual Ed, Vieja y Nueva

Bilingual education is indeed an abomination, but only because it replaces the trilingual education which served as the basis of Western learning for centuries.

We should insist that every American child-- or at least every other American child-- be taught in Spanish.  But we must be careful to choose the right dialect.  Let me suggest we adopt (or rather re-adopt) the 2000-year-old Spanish of Tácito, Livio, Horacio, Virgilio, Suetonio, César and Cicerón.

The Rockford Institute is doing just that in the ghettos of (or perhaps the ghetto that is) Rockford, Ill.  Unfortunately, they took this announcement off their Web site (http://www.rockfordinstitute.org/ ).  But note on this associated link the higher SATs and GPAs of students who choose the older Spanish over the new: http://www.bolchazy.com/al/latinadv.html

Cheers, Ron Kyser

******

The Economist on Immigration

Recall that two years ago at the Center for Immigration Studies seminar, Ben Wattenberg responded to my population query by claiming he had inside information that Census was going to revise down its projections. In fact, the new projections were: Middle series: 404 million for 2050, 571 million by 2100. High series: 553 million for 2050, 1.2 billion by 2100

Sorry Ben!

Greenspan on Immigration

I heard Mr. Greenspan state at a recent Senate hearing that he likes mass immigration to the USA as it is a "safety valve against inflationary pressures." He should be reminded that back in the 1970's we had the native born baby boomers entering the workforce en masse and we had high inflation. Most of them, like the immigrants now, took the entry-level jobs. With this in mind I have to doubt there is any "magic" that immigration is working in the economy. Thanks for a great website! I have a copy of Mr. Brimelow's book, and I'm glad to see Scott McConnell on board. I used to love his columns in the NY Post back in the mid-1990's.

Andy
White Plains, NY
February 25, 2000

Paul Gottfried writes: . . . This week Bill Kristol announced that "American conservatism has disappeared." (The New Hampshire Upheaval, Washington Post, Feb 2.) The announcement is similar to one Stalin might have made in the 1930s about vanishing Ukrainian kulaks. In any case Bill Buckley was sufficiently moved by young Kristol's discovery to devote his weekly column to the problem of an (apparently) vanishing American Right. In reality, Buckley explains, the Right has not vanished but is simply waiting for John McCain to come out unequivocally for school vouchers. It is in fact impossible to exaggerate the contemptible quality of this column, particularly the combination of triviality and groveling before Bill Kristol. [ is Professor of Humanities at Elizabethtown College in Pennsylvania.]

Scott McConnell comments: When John Podhoretz replaced me as editorial page editor of the New York Post, he told the New York Observer that I was a "very dangerous kind of conservative." I always wondered what this meant. Now I know: alive!

******

Kevin Grace writes:
RE: Stelzer
December 8, 1999

1. Did the "perk-laden corpocrats who so mismanaged America's major companies as almost to bring the economy to ruin" award themselves executive compensation of hundreds of millions a year while reducing wages at home and outsourcing millions of jobs abroad? Oh well, at least we finally understand "creative destruction."

2. Wasn't Michael Milken a criminal? Oh well, at least he wasn't a filthy "Wasp."

3. Isn't Stelzer an economist? And didn't the 1970s prove once and for all that monetary policy--not "tighter labor markets"--causes inflation? Oh well, at least we now know who is the real enemy: the native-born American worker.

4. Have you ever noticed that the pro-immigration argument is always ultimately about food? Oh well, at least we have a delicious new metaphor for the post-1965 influx: a yeast infection.

5. Go, Pat, go!

Best,


(White but neither Anglo-Saxon nor Protestant)

 

Letters for Recent, 2008, 2007, 2006, 2005, 2004, 2003