The Fulford File| Grim Sleepers? MSM And Hollywood Shut Eyes To Black Serial Killers

The idea that serial killers are almost universally white is a trope in popular culture that deserves to be discredited.

At the beginning of the movie Copycat, Sigourney Weaver, playing psychologist Dr. Helen Hudson,  asks all the men in her lecture  audience to stand, and then tells the non-white men to sit down, leaving only white men standing—because they fit the "profile" of serial killers. (This something that professors can only do to white males.)

But this is only true because she's in a movie—movies always have white, educated, urbane, and sophisticated serial killers.

In real life, however, there are a lot of black serial killers.

Robert Stacy McCain wrote a post on the accused in the "Grim Sleeper" murders, a career criminal named Lonnie Franklin, who is black.

"A small and fairly distinct group of career criminals — recidivists, habitual violators, call them what you will — account for the majority of serious crime in America. This fact was best illustrated in the early 1990s, when transit policy in New York City decided to crack down on subway turnstile-jumpers and discovered that about 15 percent of those apprehended were wanted on warrants for major felonies, including armed robbery, rape and murder.

"Murder is simply one end of a continuum of criminality and, therefore, leniency toward 'minor' crimes will inevitably result in more murders, as illustrated by the case of a suspected Los Angeles serial killer…"

[Who Commits Crime?, TheOtherMcCain.com, Posted on | July 10, 2010]

McCain is linking to a story that says

"[Lonnie David]Franklin was arrested at least 15 times for car theft, burglary, assaults and other crimes, but avoided prison despite calls by law enforcement officials for tough sentences, according to Los Angeles County court records released Friday and obtained by the Los Angeles Times.

"Franklin faced up to three years in prison in 2003 after pleading no contest to receiving stolen property, He was sentenced to 270 days in jail and released in May 2003, more than four months early, the records showed. Two months later, the body of one of Franklin's alleged victims was found."[LA Grim Sleeper suspect had 4-decade arrest record, By Christopher Weber, Associated Press, July 10, 2010. Emphasis added (by Stacy McCain)]

I need hardly say that in its reporting the Associated Press identifies the victims as young black women—but not the suspect as a middle-aged black man.

What's surprising that McCain doesn't mention it either, and illustrates his post on the general problem of serial killers coming from the ranks of unpunished petty criminals with a picture of famous white killer Charles Manson, also a petty criminal for years before he got into the killer cult business.

I blogged a while back about black serial killers, and an article called African Americans and Serial Killing in the Media | The Myth and the Reality, By Anthony Walsh, Homicide Studies, November 2005[PDF].

Walsh made a study of the actual crime statistics, and has constructed a table of crimes that tend to be forgotten.

"Table 1 provides the names of the 90 identified post–WorldWar II African American serial killers and the time period and state(s) in which they operated. Cases ranged from Monroe Hickson in 1945 to Lorenzo Gilyard and Daniel Jones in 2004. It is noted that African American serial killers were particularly well represented during the 1980s (as were White serial killers). There were 34 known African American serial killers in the 10 years from 1980 through 1989 (an average of 3.4 per year) compared with only 24 in the 34-year period between 1945 and 1979 (an average of 0.70 per year). Based on these figures, there were approximately 5 times more African American serial killers operating in the 1980s than there were from 1945 to 1979. Likewise, the 13-year period between 1990 and the first half of 2004 revealed 32 African American serial killers—an average of about 2.3 per year.  

"The 90 identified African American serial killers compose 21.8% of the sample of Black and White killers. This figure approximates the 22% estimate made by Hickey's (1997) sample of 337 serial killers of all races operating in the United States across a 165-year period.

"Far from being absent or severely underrepresented in the ranks of serial killers, then, African Americans are represented among serial killers at a rate approximately twice one would expect based on the average percentage of African Americans in the population (approximately 10.5%) across the 58-year time period examined.

"Given these findings, the next task is to try to determine why the reality is so far removed from the myth." (Emphasis added)

Actually, I think we know where the myth comes from—Hollywood, as above, for one. The protective function of the MSM's reporting habits for another.

African American comedian John Ridley has a joke that goes "You never see any black serial killers. Sure, we've got these gangs; they kill one or two people. But you white people—you're not happy 'til you got 35, 40 bodies piled up in your basement. "

Well, he's right that you never see these guys—they're not featured on Movie of the Week. But they're there. Here's the table:

You can Google any of the names, and get more information.

Note that one of the ones in the early list is Winston Moseley, who stabbed Kitty Genovese. He counts a serial killer because he killed two other women, as well. As I blogged awhile back:

"Everyone one has heard about the Kitty Genovese murder, and most of what you've heard about neighbors ignoring her screams is wrong. What you haven't heard about the Kitty Genovese murder is that her killer, Winston Mosely, is black. (A TV movie based on the Kitty Genovese murder portrayed her killer as white.) You can say 'Kitty Genovese was killed when her neighbors ignored her screams…' but you can't say 'Kitty Genovese was killed by a black man…' it's just not allowed."

So the number of black serial killers is, as Anthony Walsh, says above, "approximately twice one would expect based on the average percentage of African Americans."

That means black serial killers are only underrepresented compared to the rate of regular, normal, street-corner crime in the African American community, which is even higher—the New Century Foundation's Color Of Crime  [PDF] says that

"Blacks are seven times more likely than people of other races to commit murder, and eight times more likely to commit robbery."

Black serial killers fall below that standard. But that's all.