Immigration Depopulates Mexico and Overpopulates America

The biggest problem for the
not-very-bustling metropolis of Casa Blanca, Mexico, is,
according to a recent story
in the New
York Times
, whether it is going to exist in the near
future.  “The
question we always ask,” says one of its dwindling and
aging residents, “is, `Will our community
survive?`  We
are running out of people.”

That, of course, doesn`t mean
that the Mexican birth rate is falling. 
What it means is that too many Mexicans are
bidding adios to their homeland and heading for the
greener side of the border in El Norte—the United
States.  And
like everything else bad that happens to Mexico and
other Third World utopias-that-might-have-been, it`s
all the fault of El Gringo.

As the New
York Times
explains, (“Migrant Exodus Bleeds
Mexico`s Heartland,” June 17th) Mexicans
for many years have tracked back and forth across the
border to find work, welfare and money in the United
States and to fetch the swag back to the locals. 
But now, “Migration experts say that with a
growing United States law enforcement presence on the
border, illegal crossings have become so difficult—and
even deadly –that many migrants and their families settle
permanently in the United States, rather than to risk a
repeated crossing.”

If only we were kind enough not to
enforce our border laws and just let anyone cross who
wanted to, then the depopulation
of central Mexico wouldn`t be happening. 
It never occurs to the Times,
let alone the Mexicans, that if they stayed in their own
country where they belong, the depopulation wouldn`t
be happening either.

Nor does it occur to the Mexican
government, which is insistent on pushing more and more
of its own people out of their own country and into
ours.  The Times
again explains why, at least in part.

is a multibillion
dollar venture
for Mexico. Immigrants send home an
estimated $6.3 billion each year. 
That money—the nation`s third largest source
of income, behind oil and tourism—has not only
provided relatives money for food, clothing and
medicine.  Migrants also pooled their money and filled in for strapped
or corrupt local governments by supporting public works
projects that ranged from paving streets and installing
potable water systems to refurbishing churches and
furnishing classrooms with computers. 

So the truth is that for years
American have been subsidizing whatever passes for
progress in Mexico through the money they pay to illegal
immigrants, as well as helping to line the pockets of
the kleptocracy
that runs Mexico. 
No wonder the Mexican government doesn`t want
to do much to slow down illegal immigration and gets
testy when anyone in this country suggests that more be

The result of the virtual
abolition of the border—for all the enforcement
efforts on our side, the fact is that virtually anyone
can cross if he wants to—is the depopulation of one
and the over-population of the other. 
The state of Michaocan, for instance, in central
Mexico, sees some 50,000 of its natives leave each year,
with about half staying in the United States. 
There are now more Mexicans from this province in
California, Texas, and Illinois than there are in
Michaocan itself.

The depopulation doesn`t really
help Mexico, despite the loot the immigrants import,
because whatever human talents and skills the country
might need and be able to use tend to get out as soon as
possible.  Those who remain probably aren`t of much use for anything. 
Now, if the migrants who never come back stop
sending money back as well, the result could be further
economic collapse in their home areas, prompting still
more immigration in the future.

Meanwhile, while California`s
Gov. Gray Davis and President Bush bicker at each other
over energy policy, the truth
is that there would be no energy crisis in
California at all if it were not for the massive number
of immigrants that have swelled the state`s population
over the last 30 years. 
As demographer Virginia
points out in a recent column, California
energy consumption declined per capita over the last 20
years, but the state`s population grew by 43 percent
in the same period. 
The reason for 95 percent of the population
increase in the last decade has been immigration. 
Had those new heads not arrived to consume more
energy, there would be no energy crisis in
California—and no looming crisis for the nation. 

While Americans have subsidized
Mexican development, Mexicans and other immigrants have
helped cause our energy crisis—as well as burdens on
other resources and infra-structures. 
So we don`t really need to hear more lectures
about how Mexican depopulation is all our fault. 
If no more of them came and if the whole mass of
them went home and stayed there, both countries would be
better off. 


June 25,