Jeb Bush, hope of the GOP Establishment and champion of the donor class,
is currently twisting in the wind. But with his money and institutional support, a rebound is all too unfortunately possible. So it’s worth looking more closely at how very peculiar he is.Checked
at every turn by Donald Trump
, Jeb is even managing to make things worse for himself with various “own goals
,” from saying Americans need to work longer hours
to saying the real problem with “anchor babies” is that there are too many Asians
. Some GOP insiders
are even considering putting Mitt Romney in the race [Romney is horrified by Trump—And That’s Restarting ‘Mitt 2016’ Talk
, by Gabriel Sherman, New York,
September 1, 2015]. Put in the guy who lost last time?
What if they ran a professional sports team like they run the GOP?
But for Jeb (and by extension, some elements in the Establishment), perhaps the point isn’t to win. Perhaps the point is simply to show how pro-Hispanic they are.
Let’s look at some of Jeb’s peculiar and self-defeating stances.
On Good Morning America,
in response to George Stephanopoulos’s softball question “You know, this is also personal for you, of course,
your wife Columba comes from Mexico. What was your first thought when you heard him criticize you for speaking Spanish? “Bush responded
BUSH: I laughed. I mean, this is a joke. I was in a press gaggle where people asked me a question in Spanish and I answered it in Spanish. I was in a classroom two days ago, La Progesiva High School, where these young, beautiful kids all speak English, but they also speak Spanish and one asked a question in Spanish. I answered it. That's the reality of America, the goodness of America, that's the kind of America we want. So part of it is you laugh because it's so bizarre but it's hurtful for a lot of people and Mr. Trump know there is. He is appealing to people's angst and fears rather than higher hopes.George Stephanopoulos to Jeb Bush: Why Is Trump 'Out to Get You? NewsBusters, September 3, 2015
That’s actually reminiscent of what Brother Dubya said
when he was nominated back in 2000:
“Just go to Miami, or San Antonio, Los Angeles, Chicago or West New York, New Jersey….and close your eyes and listen. You could just as easily be in Santo Domingo or Santiago, or San Miguel de Allende. For years our nation has debated this change—some have praised it and others have resented it. By nominating me, my party has made a choice to welcome the new America.”[Mass Immigration: Its Effect on Our Culture, by Lawrence Auster, Social Contract Press, Spring 2002]
Fifteen years later, in 2015, Jeb told George Stephanopoulos that
This is a diverse country. We should celebrate that diversity and embrace a set of shared values. Mr. Trump doesn’t believe in those shared values. He wants to tear us down.
On Good Morning America
, Jeb even asked “Are we going to close all the foreign language classes
As a foreign language teacher—and of Spanish—let me respond to that, Jeb. Teaching and learning a foreign language is good, but it is a foreign language
and not the language of our country, and certainly not of our political discourse.
So what makes this guy tick? Obviously, some factors apply to any other Open Borders Republican—big donor money, the reigning touchy-feely multiculturalist zeitgeist
and conventional wisdom on the Hispanic Vote.
As with other rich folks, Jeb has not had to deal with the harmful effects of immigration. So it’s easy for him to idealize it.
And of course, there’s the also multi-generational strengthening of the multiethnic Bush Dynasty
, leadership of which would presumably pass someday to Jeb’s half-Mexican son George P. Bush
That's all true, and the bottom line is that Jeb is a True Believer in and Defender of the Emerging Hispanic Nation.
When Jeb registered to vote as “Hispanic,”
it’s because he identifies as such. Jeb may have ancestors who sailed over on the Mayflower, but what counts to him is his “Hispanic” identity. As John Derbyshire noted after reading Jeb’s immigration book, Jeb Bush Just Doesn’t Like Americans Very Much
Much of this is tied into his marriage with Columba
. Jeb and Columba were married in 1974 (and in the wedding picture
she looks whiter than she does now.) She’s been used as a campaign prop by the family since the 1980s, is apparently still uncomfortable speaking English, and reportedly
instructed her son
to “fight for our race”—referring to the Mexican side only.(George P. Bush
told a a Hispanic Republican rally in 2000
that “She told me we have to fight for our race,
we have to find the leaders who represent us”. [Reuters
, August 2, 2000] Reuters’ translation: they say he said this in “fluent Spanish.”)
Jeb claims his children were taunted for their skin color [Fiery Jeb Bush gets testy over ‘anchor babies’ term,
by Ashley Killough, CNN,
August 20, 2015]. Although Columba has been a citizen
for decades, Jeb calls her a “good Mexican” and says of himself and his family that “we are Hispanic” [Jeb Bush vows to enact comprehensive immigration reform. To Telemundo. In Spanish.
By Jazz Shaw, Hot Air,
July 28, 2015].
Needless to say, Jeb never recognizes his children’s Anglo-American heritage.
But if just having a Mexican wife were enough, I’d be a rabid Open Borders supporter. Besides that, I resided in Mexico for 15 years
and still visit twice a year.
My wife and I speak Spanish with each other, and she speaks it with our two sons
(I speak English with them).
Instead of turning out like Jeb Bush, my experience in Mexico
made me a staunch immigration patriot. And frankly, it seems as though my wife has adjusted to life in the U.S. much better than Columba has
The difference seems to be that Jeb developed a romantic image of Hispanic culture
in his youth. Jeb met Columba in 1971 when he was on a work study trip to Mexico, part of the Man and Society class he was taking at his elite Andover prep school.
put it in The Year that Changed Jeb Bush Forever,
the experience is “How a radical class—part Lord of the Flies, part Peace Corps—introduced a preppy teenager to Mexico and the love of his life” [by Michael Kruse, May 21, 2015]. Jeb himself says of the stay: “My life really began in earnest when I was 17 years old in León, Mexico.” And Politico’s
Kruse believes “[Bush’s] stubborn insistence on a doors-open immigration policy in a Republican Party that has moved away from it... can be traced back to León.”
Residing in a foreign country can indeed be a life-changing experience. Initially, everything is exotic and you are open to new perspectives. Furthermore, Jeb was a young and impressionable rich boy who fell in love.
story also contains a revealing anecdote. The Andover boys constructed a schoolhouse, with the help of a few locals, and young teaching assistant/chaperone John Patrick reported “Any Mexican peasant could do more work than two of them and keep on doing it for twice as long.”
The idea that Mexicans work harder than Americans
is very common among cheap labor profiteers.
Of course, Jeb and his Phillips Academy classmates may not have been accustomed to manual labor.
Still, the experience has stuck with him. Jeb even hired an illegal to do housework. While his father was president in 1991, Jeb’s Honduran illegal immigrant maid was deported
while Jeb was out jogging. She had worked for them for three years and “came to be part of the family.” Amazingly, given his political ambitions, Bush seems to have had no problem with her status [Bush’s maid deported, Sun Sentinel,
January 15, 1991].
Jeb Bush has a sentimental, romantic, and passionate attachment to Hispanic culture—and indifference (at best) towards the historic American nation.
Currently, Jeb is trying to say Trump i
sn’t a “true conservative” because he’s dug up old things The Donald has said and done. And Jeb might be right about some of them.
But with all Trump’s imperfections, he shows concern for working Americans. And he’s sounding better as he goes along—partially because Jeb is inspiring him to defend things like the use of English in America.
Tellingly, Jeb has not attacked Trump’s illogical and inexplicable proposal to bring the “good ones” back after deporting illegal aliens. (Let’s hope he forgets about it.) Any candidate could do it. But not Jeb, because that would be “insensitive” to Hispanic sensibilities.
So, instead, Jeb would rather lose than hurt Latino feelings. While Trump rhetorically positions himself
as a defender of the American nation, Jeb welcomes the U.S. becoming a part of the Third World. He would rather go down defending “his” invading Hispanic community—which, remember, does yet not cast even ten percent of the vote
in American elections.
What was the GOP Establishment thinking when it tied its fortunes to this freak?American citizen Allan Wall (email him) moved back to the U.S.A. in 2008 after many years residing in Mexico. Allan`s wife is Mexican, and their two sons are bilingual. In 2005, Allan served a tour of duty in Iraq with the Texas Army National Guard. His VDARE.COM articles are archived here; his Mexidata.info articles are archived here ; his News With Views columns are archived here; and his website is here.