Steyer
Memo From Middle America | Bipartisan Billionaires For Open Borders—Tom Steyer Is NOT The Opposite Of The Kochs
Default author
June 05, 2016, 08:34 PM
A+
|
a-
Print Friendly and PDF
Donald Trump has another unworthy adversary. The candidate is being attacked in a Spanish-language advertisement funded by fellow billionaire and Democratic activist/financier Tom Steyer through his NextGen Political Action Committee [Tom Steyer launches Spanish-language ads attacking Donald Trump, by Kate Linthicum, LA Times May 27, 2016).

Steyer is no novice at this sort of thing. In 2014, he pledged $100 million to Democratic candidates on condition that they oppose the Keystone Pipeline. According to The Guardian, Steyer was the biggest single donor of the 2014 election cycle. [Tom Steyer: the green billionaire pouring millions into the midterms,  By Suzanne Goldenberg, October 26, 2014] Steyer’s anti-Trump Spanish-language ads have been broadcast during the run-up to the June 7th California Primary, on Spanish-language networks Univision and Telemundo, and Spanish-language websites.

The current ad, entitled Vota (“Vote”) is brief, and actually most of the audio is in English, except the strategic conclusion.

 

What the ad does is play a couple of previous and well-publicized quotes (with audio and video) from Donald Trump, spoken by Trump in English with Spanish subtitles.

The first Trump quote, from his kickoff campaign speech:

When Mexico sends its people…..they’re rapists…
Notice that most of the speech’s original content is eviscerated, implying that Trump said that all Mexicans who go the U.S. are rapists, which he specifically did not.
“When Mexico sends its people, they are not sending their best. They are not sending you. They are sending people that have lots of problems, and they are bringing those problems to us. They are bringing drugs and they are bringing crime, and they’re rapists. Some, I assume are good people. But I speak to border guards and they tell us what we are getting.”[Watch Donald Trump Go Full Nativistby Esther Yu-Hsi Lee, ThinkProgress,  June 16, 2015]
And that segues right into the next quotation:
You’re going to have a deportation force.

We’re rounding them up in a very humane way.

It’s curious that the ad would include that part about “rounding them up in a very humane way.” Is that bad? I guess if you’re against any deportation, it doesn’t matter how you do it, it’s still bad.

With serious-sounding music playing in the background, the Trump quotes are juxtaposed the visual image of a group of serious and self-righteous looking diverse folk, including Tom Steyer himself.

Then Steyer declares in his heavily-accented Spanish,

Todos somos californianos, y es hora de alzar la voz.
For your benighted non-Spanish speakers out there, that means
“We are all Californians, and it’s time to raise our voice.”
 Then the diverse folk all say together Vota [“Vote”). And the screen shows the June 7th date of the California Primary.

Well, this brief commercial raises some real questions:

  1. What does “We are all Californians” have to do with illegal immigration and possible deportation?
Presumably, Steyer is directing his ad to American citizens in California, right? But no American citizen in California is subject to deportation.

Furthermore, immigration is a public policy issue, which American citizens in California are presumably allowed to discuss.  So what does “We are all Californians” have to do with it?

Is Steyer admitting that many current residents of California are illegal aliens? So does the term “Californian” include these illegal aliens? Is Steyer saying it’s bad to deport illegal aliens? Is he saying we can’t prevent any new illegals from entering?

Whatever the implication, it sure doesn’t sound like Tom Steyer wants our immigration laws enforced.

  1. Why make an anti-Trump video for the June 7th California primary?
On the Republican side Trump is already the virtual nominee. Thus the only way for Republicans to vote against Trump on June 7th is to vote for another candidate who has dropped out but is still on the ballot. That doesn’t accomplish much.

In the Democratic primary (which is where most of the Spanish-speakers are voting) Trump is not even a candidate.

So why run this ad now? Is it just to be whipping up more anti-Trump hysteria five months out from the general election?

  1. Why is Steyer running ads in Spanish when speaking English is a legal requirement for citizenship?
That question of course should be addressed to all politicians running Spanish-language ads in U.S. politics.

It’s relevant to point out that the Spanish Steyer ad is a slightly modified version of several other nearly identical ads in English, which use almost all the same footage. They are:

  1. Wall which is against building a border wall because “That’s not America”. This one was run before the May 23rd registration deadline in California. It tells the viewer to register and vote.
  2. Register is almost identical to Wall.
  3. Witness (15 second version here and 30 second version here)
is almost identical to the previous ones, but was aired later and tells the viewer to vote (because the registration period had ended).

Now here’s another crazy thing. Tom Steyer has been presented in the media as the Leftist version of the libertarian Koch brothers. But he denies it, though, self-righteously claiming that The Koch brothers are in it for “personal financial gain” but he’s not. [Tom Steyer’s intensifying war on Big Oil takes center stage in California,By Christopher Cadelago, Sacramento Bee, July 11, 2015 ]

(There is, however, speculation that he wants to run for California’s governor in  2018—Bay Area Billionaire Tom Steyer Spends Big As Climate Crusader, By Mike Sugerman, CBS, June 2, 2016.

But there’s something rather questionable about the whole Tom Steyer vs. Koch brothers contrast.

Despite the image of the Koch brothers as the bête noire of the Left, how are they are different from Steyer when it comes to the National Question?

I quote Julian Bradford in The ‘Kochtopus’ and Open Borders  [Social Contract Press, Summer 2014]:

If you asked any of your liberal friends to explain who the Koch Brothers are, you’d likely get a response that they were two evil men who may or may not be human and have the powers previously limited only to the great lizard people that conspiracy nuts think control the world.
And yet, when it comes to the National Question
….a significant part of their network is dedicated to promoting mass immigration to America and supporting measures that would grant permanent residency to immigrants who came to our country illegally.
Therefore,
While Democrats may love to demonize the Koch Brothers for their political donations, they should take a step back and realize that they have more in common than they might realize.
So when it comes to preserving the historic American nation, Tom Steyer and the Koch Brothers he publicly disses are on the same sheet of music. And they are all three against Donald Trump.

The bottom line, is I think explained quite simply in Trump’s definition of the term “conservative”, given at a debate :

To me I view the word conservative as a derivative of the word conserve ….We want to conserve our country, we want to save our country….”[Transcript of the New Hampshire GOP debate, annotated, The Washington Post, February 6, 2016]
Isn’t that what true conservatism actually is?

American citizen Allan Wall (email him) moved back to the U.S.A. in 2008 after many years residing in Mexico. Allan`s wife is Mexican, and their two sons are bilingual. In 2005, Allan served a tour of duty in Iraq with the Texas Army National Guard. His VDARE.COM articles are archived here; his Mexidata.info articles are archived here ; his News With Views columns are archived here; and his website is here.