Amy Chua: Tiger Mother—Or Market-Dominant Minority?

January 2011, has been
month of great divisiveness.
Yet one individual has
unified America: Amy Chua.

For the last few weeks, it has sometimes
seemed as if everybody
hated (and/or envied) the
Yale Law
professor [Email
] whose third book, Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother, recounts the hyperambitious
"Chinese mothering"
she used to nag her two daughters into being straight A
students and classical music prodigies.

example, Chua writes that her daughter can remember:

"… three things I
actually said to her at the piano as I supervised her

"Oh my
God, you`re just getting worse and worse."

"I`m going to count to three, then I want

"If the
next time`s not PERFECT, I`m going to TAKE ALL YOUR STUFFED

Ever since an excerpt was published in the
Wall Street Journal
under the title

Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior
January 8, 2011,
the public can`t get enough of the mom they love to hate.
She`s even been a superstar at

last week, among the global uberclass.

President Obama`s State of the Union address
, with its
obsessing over
Chinese competition,
had the subtext that Americans must
finally come together and unite against the Amy Chua Menace.

Yet, remarkably little attention has been
devoted to the big picture: how Chua`s new memoir relates to
her first book, World on Fire: How Exporting Free Market Democracy Breeds Ethnic Hatred and Global Instability, which I

in exactly eight years ago.

Before I get to the deepthink part of my
review of Battle Hymn
of the Tiger Mother
, let me cover a couple of issues.

Charles Murray
was the first to
point out
(and most people still haven`t noticed), Chua
can be an (intentionally) hilarious writer. I read
Tiger Mother in
about four hours and laughed out loud for maybe half of the

Chua isn`t just telling you exactly how
she feels: she`s also playing a character who is funny
because you know she`s going to tell you exactly how she feels. When satirist

Evelyn Waugh
tottered around mid-century London with a
giant Victorian
clamped to his head (which, when a postprandial
oration began to bore him, he would ostentatiously unstrap
and set on the table), he wasn`t just expressing his
reactionary curmudgeonlyness. He was also gleefully playing
his chosen role as

England`s leading curmudgeonly reactionar

Similarly, Chua works hard in her writing
to make herself the face of an increasingly important type:
the flamboyantly Asian mother who forces her children to
practice piano or violin endlessly to
good a decade from now
on their

Ivy League applications.

instance, she commiserates with her prize-winning pianist
daughter about how American pop culture doesn`t validate her
child`s Oriental docility:

"In Disney movies,
the `good daughter` always has to have a breakdown and
realize that life is not all about following rules and
winning prizes, and then takes off her clothes and runs into
the ocean … But that`s just Disney`s way of appealing to all
the people who never win any prizes. …

who is her own best audience, observes:

"I was deeply moved
by my oration."

When her
higher-testosterone younger daughter wants to drop violin
for tennis, Chua recounts:

"I compared her to
Amy Jiang, Amy Wang, Amy Liu, and Harvard Wong‒all
first-generation Asian kids‒none of whom ever talked back to
their parents. … I told her I was thinking of adopting a
third child from China, one who would practice when I told
her to, and maybe even play the cello in addition to the
violin and piano."

This looks artless, but notice how amusing
the Sino-American names sound when read out loud in that
precise order in a tone of mounting hysteria: Amy Jiang, Amy
Wang, Amy Liu, and
Wong. Or consider how much the author gets our
hopes up momentarily that she might just be crazy enough to
carry out her threatened adoption experiment. Wouldn`t you
like to know how that
would turn out?

Granted, Chua`s character in
Tiger Mom isn`t original. Many East Asian women feel as Chua does
about all the politically correct rationalizations that
whites tell each other to make America`s status climbing /
mating market games seem less Darwinian. To Chua, happy talk
is for losers. If you tell too many

genteel lies
, your children might start believing them.
And then your descendants will be

And you
know what happens to the weak …

Chua`s semi-self-parody is an up-market
version of the brilliant British comedienne

Tracey Ullman`
s character
Noh Nang Ning
, the brutally frank

donut shop owner
. Here`s a
from HBO`s 1990s sketch comedy show
Tracey Takes On of
Mrs. N coaching her nine-year-old niece at the figure
skating rink:

Nice white mom [sententiously]:
we don`t care about Henie winning … The important thing is
that my daughter go out there and have a good time."

Mrs. Noh Nang Ning [fiercely]:
"Me, too. I want niece to have
good time. You know what good time is? Winning! …"

Mrs. Noh Nang Ning [encouraging her

"You lose, you no come home!"

Nice white mom [aghast]:
can you SAY that to a child?"

Mrs. Noh Nang Ning [dismissively]:
"Good motivation. Kid no want to
sleep in box on street. … You don`t win, you nothing!"


"The next generation

[i.e., her daughters` children]
is the one I spend nights lying awake worrying about. …
Finally and most problematically, they will feel that they
have individual rights

guaranteed by the U.S. Constitution
and therefore be
much more likely to disobey their parents and ignore career
advice. In short, all factors point to this generation being
headed straight for decline.

not on my watch.

shares happy family memories:

"One jarring thing that many Chinese
people do is openly compare their children. I never thought
this was so bad when I was growing up because … my Dragon
Lady grandmother … egregiously favored me over all my
sisters. `Look how flat that one`s nose is,` she would
cackle at family gatherings, pointing at one of my siblings.
`Not like Amy, who has a fine, high-bridged nose. … That one
takes after her mother`s side of the family and looks like a

By the
way, her hugely creative father is only a minor, dissonant
character in her book. She mentions toward the end that he
wound up loathing his Dragon Lady mother for her Chinese

So much
for Chua`s humor. Secondly, what I`m sure you are all dying
to know: What`s my opinion of Chua`s childrearing

Like both Prof. Chua and many of her
detractors, I myself don`t have a large enough sample size
of children reared to generalize wildly from my own personal
experiences. Unlike both, however, I`m rather humbled by my
ignorance. So, I`m going to skip the advice-giving (other
than to say that you should
never write a
memoir featuring your children as major characters,
especially if you have more than one.)


David Brooks
, and a host of other sages have explained
that differences in natural ability are largely irrelevant
to success. The only thing that really matters is having
your child put in

10,000 hours of focused practic

Battle Hymn of the
Tiger Mother
shows you what The

10,000 Hour Rule
looks like in the real world. It`s not
a pretty sight.

As an obvious aside, let me point out that
Chua`s two high-achieving daughters chose their ancestors
wisely. Amy Chua`s paternal grandmother got rich opening
factories in the Philippines. Her father,
, Professor of Electrical Engineering at UC
Berkeley, inventor of
and the concept of the

(Hewlett-Packard is currently gearing up for
mass production of them, four decades after he dreamed them
up) has received
nine honorary
. Her mother, a chemical engineering major,
was valedictorian of her college class in Manila. The author
herself holds an endowed chair at the nation`s most
intellectually elite law school, Yale.

So does her husband,
. (They met when they were on the
Harvard Law Review.)
In his spare time, Jed wrote a 2006 murder mystery novel, The Interpretation of Murder

(in which
Freud plays detective
), that has sold over a million
copies. His father was a psychoanalyst and his mother
published a

of art critic Clement Greenberg.

You would expect less

regression toward the mean
in the offspring of family
trees with these levels of IQ, energy, and Attention Surplus
Disorder. (As Ms. Chua notes,
"As a purely mathematical fact, people who sleep less, live more.")

Chua notes that her
Chinese-Jewish-American children represent
"an ethnic group that
may sound exotic but actually forms a majority in certain
circles, especially in university towns."
It would be
interesting to try to quantify how much of the rage against
Chua in the women`s` press is motivated by inchoate feelings
that Chinese women, with their naturally straight hair, are
Stealing Our Men. (Before going to Harvard Law School,

husband studied drama at Julliard alongside Val

likes to portray herself as the stereotypical Chinese,
diligent, conventional, and uncreative:

"As the eldest
daughter of Chinese immigrants, I don`t have time to
improvise or make up my own rules. I have a family name to
uphold, aging parents to make proud. I like clear goals, and
clear ways of measuring success."

sounds like the last person to become controversial:

"I did well at

[Harvard] law school, by working psychotically hard. … But I always worried that
law really wasn`t my calling. I

didn`t care about the rights of criminals
… I also
wasn`t naturally skeptical and questioning; I just wanted to
write down everything the professor said and memorize it."

Yet you
don`t have to be extremely creative to make important
contributions to public understanding—as long as you have
the courage to tell truths that other people won`t. At the
end, Chua rants to her daughters:

these Western parents with the same party line about what`s
good for children and what`s not‒I`m not sure they are
making choices at all. They just do what everyone else does.
They`re not questioning anything, either, which is what
Westerners are supposed to be so good at doing. They just
keep repeating things like `You have to give your children
the freedom to pursue their
passion,` when
it`s obvious that the `passion` is just going to turn out to
be Facebook for ten hours …"

 Chua deals with the
kind of subjects that everybody thinks about, but we`re not
supposed to talk about. For example, Chua`s 2003 book
World on Fire was the first to acquaint me with one of the key facts
of the history of the

. Chua wrote:

THE spring of 2000, a professor whom I`ll call

Jerry White
was furiously trying to finish an article on
the debacle of Russian privatization. … It seemed to me that
most of the

key players in the privatization of Russia
were Jewish.

“`Oh, no,` Jerry
replied instantly. `I don`t think so.`

“`Are you sure?` I
pressed him. `If you look at their names . . . `

“`You can`t tell
anything from names,` Jerry snapped, clearly not wanting to
discuss the topic any further.

“As it turns out, six out of seven of
Russia`s wealthiest and, at least until recently, most
powerful oligarchs are Jewish."

Google News

1,570 recent news articles about
"Amy Chua". Yet

only two of those
go on to

the crucial term she coined in
World on Fire"market-dominant
—to describe groups like her own

Overseas Chinese

Ashkenazis in Yeltsin`s Russia.

You may
think I`m just dragging the topic of the day around to my
own area of interest, but Chua explains in her new memoir
the origin of her first book:

"Combining my law degree with my own
family`s background, I would write about law and ethnicity
in the developing world. Ethnicity was my favorite thing to
talk about anyway"

Chua`s ancestors were from southeastern
province "which is
famous for producing scholars and scientists"
Traditionally, Fujianese led in the mandarin civil service
exams and today in China`s college admission test.

Chua`s parents grew up in the

, where a small number of Chinese own most of
that country`s business assets. The population of the
Philippines has grown from 28 million a half century ago to

92 million
in 2009, so there`s not all that much to go

In Southeast Asia, the Chinese have most
of the money, but the

natives have most of the guns
. So, when Chua`s aunt in
Manila was murdered by her Filipino chauffeur who then fled,
the Filipino policemen made only derisory efforts to find
and arrest their co-ethnic. Sure, he`s a murderer, the
Filipino cops seem to have reasoned, but he`s our murderer.
And that rich Chinese woman probably had it coming.

place …

rich family comes from a poor world where there`s room for
only a few at the top to live well. They do what it takes to
stay on top. She has inherited these worries:

"One of my greatest
fears is family decline. There`s an old Chinese saying that
`prosperity can never last for three generations.`"

Of course, 19th Century Americans had a

a century ago: From shirtsleeves to shirtsleeves
in three generations.

Yet this
American version never had quite such a Malthusian ring to
it. If a 19th Century American family fell out of riches,
they weren`t in danger of Oriental poverty. They were still
a 19th Century American family—with a giant new country to
try their luck in.

Why has
life in America generally been less stressed-out than in
other parts of the world?

America has traditionally been a lot nicer
place than China or the Philippines. We Americans like to
dream up self-congratulatory reasons for this. Some of them
might even be true. But a big reason is simply that

America is less crowded
—and thus less competitive.

Back in 1751, the highest achiever of all
Americans, Benjamin Franklin,


greater happiness of life in America
: because a
middle-class life is more affordable for the average person
in empty America than elsewhere.

Unfortunately, our elites have been working to erase that

[Steve Sailer (email
him) is

movie critic

The American Conservative

His website

features his daily blog. His new book,