Lawsuit against Ground Zero Mosque Dismissed
The battle to stop the hostile Ground Zero mosque (an attempt of Muslims to mark territory) continues. A recent lawsuit was dismissed on the basis that firefighter Tim Brown did not have standing to sue. However, he indicated in a recent interview that he and others against a mosque being built so close to Ground Zero were not giving up.
Ground Zero Mosqueâ€™ Clears Legal Hurdle to Build, ABC News, July 13, 2011 The backers of the controversial â€?Ground Zero Mosqueâ€? have won a court fight clearing the way for them to build the mosque and community center complex two blocks from the site of the 9/11 terror attack. In a decision on Friday that was made public today, New York State Supreme Justice Paul Feinman dismissed a lawsuit by former firefighter Timothy Brown who argued that New York City was wrong to allow the destruction of a 150-year-old building to make way for the Islamic center. The ex-firefighter who was among those who responded to the terror attack on the World Trade Center said the old building had been struck by debris during the collapse of the twin towers and was a â€?living representative of the heroic structures that commemorate the events of that day.â€? In a 15-page decision Feinman wrote, â€?Mr. Brownâ€™s claim that his ability to commemorate will be injured, is not yet recognized under the law as a concrete injury that can establish standing. Such an injury, although palpable to Brown, is immeasurable by a court.â€? The American Center for Law and Justice, a conservative legal group which filed the lawsuit on Brownâ€™s behalf, said they plan to appeal the ruling. Ground Zero Mosque Clears Legal Hurdle to Build â€?This decision fails to give appropriate consideration to first responders and others who risked their lives and lost loved ones on Sept. 11,â€? ACLJ attorney Brett Joshpe said in a statement. The ACLJ â€?remain confident that this mosque will never rise above Ground Zero.â€? Organizers of the project, officially called Park 51, declined to comment. Brown and the ACLJ were appealing a ruling last summer by the cityâ€™s Landmarks Preservation Commission which decided to allow a 150-year-old Park Place building to be razed to make way for the center. Park 51 has been a source of national controversy since its unveiling last May. Opponents as well as supporters demonstrated at Ground Zero in reaction to the commissionâ€™s decision to allow the mosque last August. President Obama was drawn into the controversy when he initially endorsed the mosque. â€?As a citizen, and as president, I believe that Muslims have the same right to practice their religion as anyone else in this country,â€? Obama said at a White House ceremony last summer that marked the Islamic holy month of Ramadan. â€?That includes the right to build a place of worship and a community center on private property in lower Manhattan in accordance with local laws and ordinances.â€? But in a visit to the Gulf Coast, Obama later dialed back saying that he supported the Muslims communityâ€™s right to build the mosque, but was not sure it was a good idea to build so close to Ground Zero.